Official Reddit reUnited Clash of Clans forum


    Clan War donating idea

    Share
    avatar
    BallsJr

    Posts : 43
    Join date : 2014-04-08
    Location : Michigan, USA

    Clan War donating idea

    Post by BallsJr on Wed 02 Jul 2014, 12:51

    Hello folks, BallsJr here! 

    After quite a few clan wars, I think that I have an idea that would help out our clan war donations quite a bit! As you may notice, it seems as if there are only a few people donating to clan castles in the war bases. I may have an idea to fix this if we all take part. 

    Wars on Wednesday/Thursdays: ODD numbered war bases donate FIRST this day! My idea is that the odd numbers (1,3,5,...) donate to the base directly beneath them. 1 would donate to 2,3 and 4, 3 donates to 1 and 5, THEN, 5 donates to 6 and 7, 7 donates to 8 and 9, etc. Number one gets kind of screwed but then again, Gandalf is the highest level and it has to work somehow. 

    Wars on Friday/Saturdays: EVEN numbered war bases donate FIRST this day! My idea is that the even numbers (2,4,6,...) donate to the base directly beneath them. 2 would donate to 1,3, and 4, 4 donates to 2, 5, and 6, and THEN, 6 donates to 7 and 8, 8 donates to 9 and 10, etc. Sorry to 2 and 4 but it is tough when things get to be like this, and this is my opinion to the best way to do it. 


    These requests MUST be filled exactly as requested. If you would like to donate more, then start from the LOWEST bases and donate some to those. When you donate, you have to give them the troops that cost the most first (if someone wants wiz and arch, don't give them 5 archers, give them 5 wizards). If the request cannot be filled, please ask someone else to get them for you or something. 

    READ THIS: Requests should be filled by 3 hours until war day. When 3 hours hits, the OPPOSITE NUMBERS fills the rest in. You may choose whichever bases but you should fill every base to the best of your ability. So on WED/THURS wars, evens fill with 3 hours left and on FRI/SAT wars, odds fill with 3 hours left. 

    Requests will have to become specific to level if someone is unhappy with who is donating to them. The entire reason I made this is because it seems as if only about 15 people would fill all the CCs every war and this way, it is spread out more. 

    If you have suggestions or questions, please ask me, I understand that this is very confusing and am ready to answer any questions. The only people that don't donate to the 2 bases below them are 1,2, and 4, but you don't have to know about that. Let me know what you think! 

    -BallsJr
    avatar
    Gandalf
    Admin

    Posts : 168
    Join date : 2014-02-08
    Location : The Netherlands

    Re: Clan War donating idea

    Post by Gandalf on Thu 03 Jul 2014, 01:27

    Thx Balls for putting this together. As already mentioned in chat I like the idea and want to build upon as the situation was worse the last two wars where I filled almost all clan castles on my own and to make things perfectly clear this ain't gonna happen anymore. If we still don't get the concept that your own success depends on your clan mates and vise versa guess having a war with empty clan castles will bring the point across.

    Now back to your idea. I like to suggest making things a bit more simple as that is what I like. Every war we pair the highest with the lowest, second highest with second lowest and fill cc as requested. This would get us the best troops in our lowest level cc's. In a 50-50 war #1 would fill cc of #50, #2 pairs up with #49, etc. This would also allow us to track who did not donate (not precisely but I will come back to that).
    In addition our average cc size is around 30 and if everybody contributes this is not a too big of a number and we should all be able to make this number. This means that if you have filled the cc of your buddy with let's say 5 wizzies you still need to donate 10 troops in the next cc up for the players at the top half of the map and down for the players on the bottom half of the map. So if their are troops in the cc you would not exactly know who donated but if there are NO troops we exactly know who does not play ball.
    avatar
    Slackers

    Posts : 113
    Join date : 2014-02-16
    Location : The Netherlands

    Re: Clan War donating idea

    Post by Slackers on Thu 03 Jul 2014, 01:41

    All i can say is that this is a great idea! Gand gave great feedback already. Nothing more to say about it.
    avatar
    BallsJr

    Posts : 43
    Join date : 2014-04-08
    Location : Michigan, USA

    Re: Clan War donating idea

    Post by BallsJr on Thu 03 Jul 2014, 05:08

    Now Gand, when you say 1 pairs with 50, 2 with 49, etc, would that mean 49 would pair with 2? The reason I did it the way I stated was due to the fact that even though it might be a small difference, is that the level of the troops might not be good enough. Example: I think you have lvl 6 mins and if you want minions, the number 50, 45, or 40 guy or whatever may only have level 1 minions. Your idea is much more simple but I'm just worried on the slight difference in troop level.

    Sponsored content

    Re: Clan War donating idea

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Mon 23 Oct 2017, 15:03